If you sell more than about twenty products, or you need stock to stay accurate, use Shopify. If you sell three things and they rarely change, you probably do not need a commerce platform at all. The hard cases sit in between, and they usually come down to inventory rather than product count.
What Shopify is actually solving
It is easy to underestimate, because the shop front looks like the whole thing. The part you are really buying is everything behind it.
- Checkout. PCI compliance, fraud checks, saved cards, wallets. The most optimised step of the funnel, maintained by people whose whole job that is.
- Inventory. Stock counts that stay right across channels, including when two people buy the last one at once.
- Tax and shipping. Rates by region, calculated correctly, kept current as rules change.
- Orders. Refunds, partial refunds, fulfilment, notifications, receipts.
Rebuilding that is not a website project. It is a product.
When your existing site is enough
A few products, stable stock, no variants. In that case you can sell from a site built in Astro with a hosted checkout link, and skip the platform fee entirely.
This works well for:
- A handful of digital products or downloads.
- Event or workshop tickets.
- A short run of merchandise.
- Made to order work where stock is not a number.
You keep one fast site, one codebase, and no monthly commerce bill. What you give up is anything that depends on knowing how many you have left.
The middle ground
You can have both. Shopify runs the commerce engine through its API while the site stays on Astro or Next.js. The product pages are yours, and checkout hands off to Shopify.
This is worth it when the storefront has to do something unusual, such as a configurator or a map of stockists, and you still want Shopify’s checkout and inventory. It costs more to build and gives you the best of both. Do not pick it to save money, because it does not.
The costs people forget
On Shopify: the platform fee is the small part. Apps are where the real monthly cost lands, and each one adds script weight to every page. A store with twelve apps is usually both expensive and slow. Transaction fees apply too unless you use Shopify Payments.
On a custom build: you are responsible for anything the platform would have handled. Tax changes, a payment provider’s API update, a new wallet everyone suddenly expects. That work does not appear in the build quote.
How to decide
Ask these four, in order.
- Does stock need to be accurate? If yes, use a platform.
- Will the catalogue grow past about twenty items? If yes, use a platform.
- Do you need variants, bundles or subscriptions? If yes, use a platform.
- Is someone non technical adding products? If yes, use a platform.
Four noes and your current site can probably carry it.
If you are not sure which side you fall on, tell us what you sell and how stock works, and we will give you a straight recommendation.