Custom Astro websites. Built on Cloudflare.

Explore Plyo

Mapbox vs Google Maps vs MapTiler

A practical comparison of the three map platforms we use most, covering design control, data, pricing models and which suits which project.

A line drawing of three map panels side by side, the middle one pinned on a pale green cover

When a website needs a map, the first decision is which platform to build on. We work with Mapbox, Google Maps and MapTiler regularly. Each is good at something different.

The short version

  • Google Maps: best when people expect the familiar Google map, with directions, places and Street View
  • Mapbox: best for fully custom map design and polished data visualisation
  • MapTiler: best for open standards, self-hosting options and avoiding lock-in

Google Maps

Strengths

  • The map everyone recognises
  • Rich place data: business details, opening hours, reviews
  • Directions, Street View and geocoding built in
  • Strong address search

Trade-offs

  • Less design control than Mapbox or MapTiler. You can restyle colours, but it will still look like Google
  • Usage-based pricing across many separate services, which can be hard to predict for busy sites
  • Terms restrict how Google’s data can be stored and displayed

Good for: store finders where people want directions, contact pages, local service businesses.

Mapbox

Strengths

  • Complete control over every colour, label, line and layer, through Mapbox Studio
  • Excellent performance with large datasets, using vector tiles and GPU rendering
  • Strong tools for 3D, terrain and animated data
  • Good geocoding and routing services

Trade-offs

  • Pricing is based on map loads and API requests beyond a free tier
  • Its newer map library has a proprietary licence, so it is tied to Mapbox’s services

Good for: branded maps, property and development projects, data-heavy visualisations.

MapTiler

Strengths

  • Built on open standards and open data, including OpenStreetMap
  • Works with MapLibre, a fully open-source map library
  • Options to host tiles yourself, for example on Cloudflare
  • Good design control and a range of ready-made styles

Trade-offs

  • Smaller ecosystem than Google or Mapbox
  • Place and business data is less rich than Google’s

Good for: projects that need to stay portable, government and infrastructure work, sites with very high traffic where self-hosting keeps costs steady.

Google Maps Mapbox MapTiler
Design control Moderate Very high High
Place data Excellent Good Basic
Open source option No Partly Yes, with MapLibre
Self-hosting No No Yes
Familiar to users Very Less Less

Choose the map platform for what your visitors need to do, not just what looks good in a screenshot.

A note on pricing

All three offer free usage allowances and charge for usage above them, but they count usage differently. Pricing also changes from time to time, so we check each provider’s current rates against your expected traffic before recommending one.

Updated

FAQ

Common questions

Ask a question

Which map is best for SEO?

None of them directly. Search engines can’t read map tiles. What helps is a text list of locations with addresses and structured data alongside the map.

Can I switch map providers later?

Yes, though the effort depends on how the map is built. Using open formats for your data, like GeoJSON, makes switching much easier.

Can you put our own GIS data on a web map?

Yes. We convert data from tools like QGIS and ArcGIS into web-friendly formats and build maps around it.

About Plyo Studio

Custom Astro websites. Built on Cloudflare.

Plyo Studio is an independent web studio that designs and builds fast, search-ready websites, web apps and interactive maps. Sites are custom-built in Astro and hosted on Cloudflare, so they load quickly and are easy for search engines and AI answer engines to read.

Founded by Chloe Nixon, a full stack developer and UI/UX designer from Australia, and Micky, a software engineer from New Zealand. Clients work directly with the founders from the first call to launch. Typical work: custom websites, migrations off Webflow, WordPress, Wix and Squarespace, web apps, and interactive maps and GIS. Projects are quoted at a fixed price before work starts.